What is a Discussion Essay (Both Views)?
A discussion essay presents both sides of a controversial topic fairly before presenting your own position. It's a frequent IELTS Task 2 format that tests balanced reasoning and analytical skills.
A discussion essay with both views examines opposing opinions equally, then concludes with your stance. Structure: introduction → view 1 → view 2 → your opinion → conclusion.
- •Benefit A
- •Reason B
- •Evidence C
- •Drawback A
- •Concern B
- •Counter-evidence C
Step-by-step worked examples
Prompt: 'Some people believe university education is essential for success; others think practical skills matter more. Discuss both sides and your opinion.'
View 1 (Pro university): Qualifications, social networks, better salaries. View 2 (Pro skills): Plumbers/electricians earn well, less debt, faster career start. Your stance: Both complement each other; ideal path combines formal + vocational training. Conclusion: Context and passion determine the better route.
Prompt: 'Should governments invest in renewable energy or fossil fuels? Discuss both.'
View 1 (Renewables): Sustainable, cost-dropping, no pollution. View 2 (Fossil fuels): Proven infrastructure, cheaper now, millions employed. Your stance: Renewable shift necessary despite transition costs. Conclusion: Long-term climate imperative outweighs short-term fossil comfort.
Prompt: 'Is remote work beneficial or harmful? Discuss both views.'
View 1 (Pro): Flexibility, time saved commuting, work-life balance. View 2 (Con): Isolation, lower productivity, communication gaps, career stagnation. Your stance: Remote works for some roles/personalities, not all. Conclusion: Hybrid models best suit diverse workforce needs.
Flashcards
Quick quiz
Q1.In a both-views essay, after presenting side 1, what comes next?
Q2.How should you present the opposing view?
Q3.What is the tone of a both-views essay?
Q4.Can you change your opinion in the conclusion?
The full card deck, worked steps and AI-tutor support for “What is a Discussion Essay (Both Views)?” are in Notek — study by hand before your exam.
Common mistakes
Presenting one side weakly to favor your own. — Correct: Make both sides strong so your final stance is clearly justified.
Using biased language ('Obviously, sensible people believe…'). — Correct: Neutral language: 'Proponents argue…', 'Critics contend…'.
Forgetting to state your own opinion. — Correct: Clearly declare your stance in the body or conclusion.
Treating the views as equally valid without judgment. — Correct: After presenting both, explain why one or a compromise is stronger.
FAQ
What is a discussion essay with both views?
An essay presenting two opposing viewpoints fairly, then stating your reasoned stance.
How long should each view paragraph be?
Similar length — roughly equal space makes the discussion feel balanced and fair.
Should I agree with one side completely?
You can, but first justify why the opposing view is weaker. A balanced conclusion often works best.
What is the difference between 'both views' and 'opinion'?
'Both views' presents opposing sides first; 'opinion' focuses on your stance from the start.